• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • KW
  • About
  • Books
    • I Choose Brave
    • But then she remembered
  • Speaking
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

Katie Westenberg

I Choose Brave

  • Living Brave
  • Brave Faith
  • Brave Marriage
  • Parenting Brave
  • Brave Friend

When You Question God’s Faithfulness

by Katie

Ten years ago today I found it hard to get out of bed.  Leveled by a weight I didn’t completely understand or see coming, I struggled to find my footing.  I hid.

Go into labor in an instant, be rushed to the hospital by ambulance, deliver a lifeless baby and hold her in your arms…and the world kind of stops.

Have you ever questioned God's faithfulness? Like you know God is good, but you sometimes wonder if He is really good...to you. Ten years from some of the hardest days of my life, I'm overwhelmed by His faithfulness through it all.

 

Leave the hospital no longer pregnant, no longer with child, just in time to meet with the funeral director, because there are choices that have to be made, papers that have to be signed and it’s all so hard to hard to process.  It happens so quickly.

Where am I and how did I even get here?

In the days that follow you try to put one foot in front of the other, put the pieces of normal back together, but it’s a puzzle where nothing seems to fit no matter how much you will it to.  Everything has changed.

There was still a sweet one year old to mother, a husband who was trying to process the same nightmares, friends and family who wanted so much to help, wanted in, and I mostly couldn’t find the strength to open the door more than a crack.

The next year was hard.  It sucked.  I realize that’s not a pretty word, but it feels disingenuous to paint pretty words on the ugliest of times.

I cried when my close friend told me she was pregnant – with a girl.  She was nervous to tell me.  I offered congratulations, hung up the phone and bawled.  I did the same another day as I walked by the little girls shoe section in a department store.

I knew God was good, but why did it feel like he wasn’t good to me?  I prayed big prayers for my daughter.  I rested and didn’t do yard work when I knew things were complicated.  I followed the rules, fought for faith over fear.  And here is where it all got me, bawling in the shoe department.

In the months that followed, months and months of hoping to become pregnant again, fear became a cancer in my heart.  What if this is it for me?  What if there are no more babies?  What if there never is another little girl?

The questions were real and honest and painful.

My double portion. God is always faithful.

 

And ten years later, I find myself here – mama to two lively, healthy and beautiful girls (not to mention, two awesome boys, as well).  I can’t look a them without realizing God has given me nothing less than a double portion.

 

B&B Birthday Collage

 

They are two peas in a pod, these girls, nearly the same size and preferring to dress the same much of the time, as well.  We celebrated them last night as they turned 6 & 8, just days apart.   And my heart felt overwhelmed.  Amidst the festivities, I couldn’t help but realize that God saw every angry and bitter tear that I cried, knowing I would be right here today.  He knew there would be beauty from those ashes, that I would one day be able to share my story and hold another woman’s hand in her pain.

And He sees you too.

I still don’t have suffering all figured out.  I don’t have a canned answer for the whys and hows, a pretty band-aid for the pain.  I’ve much to keep learning and I suspect I won’t completely understand it all until I see the face of the One who made me.  But I know that He is faithful.  And He is good.  Even, to me.

 

A double portion Isaiah 61.7.

 

This post has been linked at #TellHisStory.

Share52
Email
Pin320
Print
Post
372Shares

You may also enjoy...

Filed Under: Brave Faith, Brave Mama Tagged With: faith

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Carrie says

    December 14, 2016 at 6:30 am

    I needed to hear this. Thank you!

    • Katie says

      December 15, 2016 at 5:15 am

      My pleasure, Carrie. <3

  2. Tiff says

    July 15, 2016 at 5:52 am

    I love when you share your story. So many can relate to you. Transparency makes us all human, vulnerable.
    Your girls are growing so fast! Hugs to you & yours

    • Katie says

      July 15, 2016 at 7:39 am

      Thank you, friend. Those are always the hardest words for me.

  3. Niki Larson says

    July 6, 2016 at 6:46 pm

    I just love the candor of your posts. I never lost a baby; but it sure felt like it after praying for a baby girl for so long. I had an ultrasound that was a probable girl and got a boy on April fools day of all days. All this after baby number one (also a boy) was born and I was told he shouldn’t have been and I may never have another. Being diagnosed with PCOS left me feeling overwhelmed with grief and less of a woman because my body could not perform the basic function a commanded function of going forth to multiply. And even though I was not saved at the time and probably because I wasn’t I felt God punishes me.
    Years later we decided to try for baby three and I prayed, I begged and I pleaded for a baby girl. I even had a dream so vivid of this beautiful little girl around 3-4 years old with curly brown hair and green eyes; wearing a white with blue floral runt dress, leggings, a jean jacket shrug and baby ugh boots. So I thought for sure she would be real this time. I had several ultra sounds with baby three because I had pre-eclampsia and when the ultra sound tech said I see scrotum I couldn’t feel the blessing God gave me in my 3rd boy, all I felt was loss and betrayal. I cried most of the way home from the doctor ( a 2 hour trip). I had the bedding I bought for baby #2 , pretty pink feminine baby girl bedding and all I could do was cuddle it, weeping over a loss that really wasn’t a loss. I mourned for years and my sons are now 18, 12, and 7.
    One time when I was praying pleading really to Father God about all the things I felt He hadn’t given me, all the ways He hadn’t blessed me, it hit me that His love, His grace, His mercy, He is sufficient for me is when I finally decided to let go of her. It still hurts but not as bad. I still wonder sometimes what she would be like, how different our lives would be, but how we wouldn’t have Sawyer or Bridger if she was here. Often times I think we decide God is not good when bad happens because we equate what is good as what WE deem is fair. Life isn’t fair, And Gods plan is not our plan. If He gave us what we think we deserve it could change the coarse of that plan. If He gave us what we truly deserve well I guess the wage of sin is death and I would be in the grave.
    God bless,
    Niki Larson

    • Katie says

      July 7, 2016 at 5:34 am

      Niki, thank you so much for bravely and honestly sharing your story. I can’t think of any way God has shaped my heart more acutely than the process of having children. The wanting and not wanting and hoping and hurting and “let’s have more”, “no, let’s not have more” has been so much harder than I ever thought it would be, yet it has forced me to understand more clearly than ever that He is God and I am not. The selfish and headstrong planner part of me gets that confused at times. It’s definitely a blessing to look back over time and see that even though some things were hard, He is so very good.

  4. Sheila Qualls says

    July 3, 2016 at 7:17 pm

    So hard to understand God in the hard times. Hard to believe that He is good. Thanks for sharing the painful memory and the blessings.

    • Katie says

      July 4, 2016 at 6:03 am

      Yes, Sheila. I’m thankful for time and perspective. All these years later I am still learning, still seeing Him bring beauty from those ashes.

  5. Amy Christensen says

    July 3, 2016 at 1:48 pm

    Thanks for your honesty. I have never had the pain of a losing a child in this way. But obviously, God knows what He is doing, even when we don’t understand. Trust is huge! Thanks for reminding us. – Amy
    http://stylingrannymama.com/

    • Katie says

      July 4, 2016 at 5:58 am

      Exactly, Amy. And while suffering is so very hard, the opportunity to see God’s grace and providence through it is an incredible gift. Thanks for reading.

  6. Yemisi says

    July 3, 2016 at 9:11 am

    Our God is indeed a good God. I relate perfectly with your story. Wentbto hospital pregnant and leaving without a child. Mine happened 14years ago and I still remembered how I couldn’t cry for days asking Him to explain to me what happened and 3days after I lost my baby boy He walked into my room early in the morning at the hospital, hug me and whispered to me ‘ I know what’ just trust me and I was able to let down the tears. He has blessed me with two lovely boys 13 & 11 years and I know beyond any doubt that God is indeed faithful

    • Katie says

      July 4, 2016 at 5:53 am

      Wow, Yemisi, what a beautiful story. It’s interesting how grief can look a little different for all of us, but the same God carries us through it. Thank you for sharing your story with me. <3

  7. Maria adame says

    July 2, 2016 at 10:32 pm

    Thank you for sharing your stories. I came across your post and instantly i was hooked. However, I didnt know at the time that i would soon be in your place. I had a feeling somthing wasnt right with my pregnancy but i pushed through it with faith. However, God had his plan. It hurts. Im slowly moving forward. I know God is good. Lord knows hes taken very good care of us and blessed us with a beautiful healthy happy little girl already. Shes more than i ever expected. But I hope that God continues to have pateince with me thru this time. I cant say i have it together and that my walk with him is stronger than ever before. Nevertheless, i havent let him go. But i pray that i can be as strong as you are and that my faith would be where it was, if not stronger. I hope God continues to bless you with the desires of your heart. Thank you for your words and the hope to give to those like me. God bless you

    • Katie says

      July 3, 2016 at 6:00 am

      I’m so sorry, Maria. Please know I’ve had a lot of time to get here; it was a slow process. One thing I’ve come to realize is God completely understands hurt, pain and loss. Jesus felt that when both John the Baptist and Lazarus died. I can only imagine how it grieved God when his own some Jesus was crucified. He gets it. And there is so much grace there. Try to be as patient with yourself as He is with you. I’m praying for you this morning and I am thankful you found your way here, Maria. <3

  8. leanne says

    July 2, 2016 at 11:14 am

    Such an encouraging post. Celebrate big!

    • Katie says

      July 2, 2016 at 3:26 pm

      We sure did, Leanne!

  9. Anna says

    July 2, 2016 at 9:53 am

    Yes, that He is. I relate to this post so much. 5 babies in Heaven and I cannot help but stand in awe of the 6 lives He has now blessed me with… Amazing God!

    • Katie says

      July 2, 2016 at 3:25 pm

      5, wow. I never knew, Anna. Interesting how you can look at a person’s beautiful family and never know the long road that led them there. Everyone has a story, don’t they? We are blessed to learn so much of Him along the way.

Primary Sidebar

 

Katie Westenberg

Hey, friend, I’m glad you’re here! I’m Katie. One girl determined to do life bravely. One girl determined to Fear God and Live Brave, to parent well, live authentically and work hard for all the things that matter. I Choose Brave and I hope you will too!

Enter your e-mail address in the box below and join thousands of women in the brave community here. It’s the simplest way to keep in touch and stay encouraged!

Posts You’ll Love!

Raising Overcomers: How to Teach Your Kids to do Hard Things

Identity Crisis: How to Help Your Children Know Their Worth

The Power of a Mother’s Words

Pre-Order Now

But Then She Remembered

Buy This Book Online
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Amazon Kindle
Buy from Christian Book Distributor
Buy from Barnes and Noble
Baker Book House
But Then She Remembered
Buy now!
This is fun news! For a limited time, buy a copy o This is fun news! For a limited time, buy a copy of But Then She Remembered for MOM and we’ll send YOU a copy of the audiobook for free!

Distraction is a multi-generational struggle. Remembering is a multi-generational command. Let’s do this, together. Here are the details:

Purchase your copy of But Then She Remembered from any retailer and then head to my website (link in bio) to get your free copy of the audiobook. It’s that simple.
.
Available while supplies last. (Note: the offer says buy a copy for mom, not necessarily YOUR mom. Buy a copy for a woman who is a mom, or a woman who has a mom. 😊 They all qualify. Just grab it before they’re gone!}
I scanned a post shared by a friend awhile back an I scanned a post shared by a friend awhile back and the words quickly wooed me. I’ve long been a sucker for words.
.
The writer spun them expertly, thoughtfully, vividly, and I was glad to drink of her craft, greedy for story drawn artfully, delivered thoughtfully, from a deep well.

Until I realized, the words weren’t true. The author was believing a well woven lie and carefully threading mistruth into her own kind of gospel. Her mastery, a thin veil for mistruth.
.
I was reminded, friend, perhaps the apple looks a bit different today. The shape and size, delivery method, have gone modern but the Truth is still the same - sin is crouching, desiring us and we are commanded to rule over it. Still, today.
.
We must know Truth to spot lies. We must remember it, to recognize the difference. We must be aware of our weaknesses and the sticky compulsion of temptation. It’s our responsibility to rule here. May we do so, bravely..
.
{Genesis 4:7 
And more like this in the newly released, But Then She Remembered.}
This morning, remember. This morning, remember.
Just a little PSA to remind you - it’s possible. Just a little PSA to remind you - it’s possible. 

It’s possible to be aware of the news and the world, of foreign relations and politics, and not be obsessed about it.

It’s possible to feel the real hurt of real trouble and not be possessed by it.

It’s possible to be in the world and not of it. To remember who God was, and is, and always will be, above it.

It’s possible to remember Him here.

May we learn to do so, bravely.
.

{Beautifully modeled in Psalm 77. See for yourself, friend.❤️}
Slow processor over here. But this little book lau Slow processor over here. But this little book launched into the world on Tuesday and I’m still reeling from the beauty of celebrating side by side with so many sisters, the grace of what it looks like when so many women offer their gifts for His glory (fishes and loaves never looked so good!), and the incredible support of my local community. I’ll never forget it.
.
If you want to join us as women determined to remember the goodness of God in this wildly distracting world, grab yourself a copy of the book and LET’S GO! We are ready for it.❤️
HOW SWEET IS THIS? My dear friend @jodie_berndt an HOW SWEET IS THIS? My dear friend @jodie_berndt and I get to release books on the very same day - tomorrow! To celebrate @growthrootsco (another dear friend and creator of the loveliest journals) is giving YOU a chance to win copies of them all!

Here’s the offering:

1. My book - But then she remembered (how to give God your full attention in a distracted world)
2. Jodie’s book - Praying the scriptures for your marriage (trusting God with your most important relationship)
3. A growth book! 
4. Jodie’s favorite pens!
5. An Amazon gift card!! 
6. Marriage conversation cards! 

Beautiful, right? I know these women, their love for Jesus, their work and their words. You will LOVE these books, friend (and the extra goodies too). 

Here’s how to enter:

1. Follow @jodie_berndt, @katie_westenberg and @growthrootsco

2. Tag 3 friends (or more 😉 each tag or share gives you another entry) 

3. Like this post.

That’s it! The giveaway will close Wednesday night and the winner will be announced Thursday! 

*Giveaway open to U.S residents only. As per Instagram’s rules, this promotion is not sponsored, administered, or associated with Instagram in any way.*
The humanity of Jesus Christ is an indispensable g The humanity of Jesus Christ is an indispensable gift to us as believers. Every challenge we face He met and mastered. The Bible doesn’t speak of endless notifications and group texts, but it does speak of people with real needs showing up in Christ’s path constantly. 
.
Wherever He went crowds followed with needs and questions and frustrations and problems. He got in a boat to cross to the other side of the sea, and people would race to meet Him there. 

Can you even imagine?

And His most common response? He was moved with compassion. 
.
Over and over again, He stopped what He was doing, paused from the task at hand, and tended to the needy hearts - the bleeding woman, the woman at the well - right in front of Him.
.
Far too often I find I’m happy to entertain distractions - anything that prevents me from giving my full attention to something else - and yet annoyed by interruptions. Perhaps it is because one I choose, while the other I do not?
.
Discerning the difference between a distraction and an interruption has been a helpful tool to me. I want to love like Christ. I want to be interruptible, but I want to give my full attention to what He places in my path.
.
What about you? Are you more frustrated by distractions or interruptions?
.
.
.
{excerpt from But Then She Remembered: How to Give God Your Full Attention in a Distracted World.}
UPDATE: You all scooped up dozens of copies in min UPDATE: You all scooped up dozens of copies in minutes! 🎉 Well done! You know how to love your leaders well. I wish we had another case of books to give away! We are closing this giveaway for now. If you sent us a message watch for a reply soon!
****

I need your help with something fun! 
.
This little book is making its way out into the world and instead of sending all of the marketing copies to all of the “influencer” people, we’ve held a supply back for the real people on the ground. 
.
These copies are for the women’s ministry leaders and the Bible study leaders. The small group leaders and women out there mentoring and serving others in quiet and unseen places. The women without a platform or audience in the world’s currency, but willing to do good and important work for the women right in front of them.
.
I’m convinced this work of leading and serving face to face is more important than ever and I want to say thank you! And keep going! Your work matters.
.
So here is how it works: If you are a local leader or know of one who you would like me to send a copy of my hot-off-the-press book, But Then She Remembered: How to Give God Your Full Attention in a Distracted World, DM me with a name and mailing address. I’ll send them a copy of the book with a personal thank you note for the good work they are doing.
.
Crash my inbox. We’ll send ‘em out while supplies last!

Copyright © 2025 · Katie Westenberg · All Rights Reserved