• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • KW
  • About
  • Books
    • I Choose Brave
    • But then she remembered
  • Speaking
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

Katie Westenberg

I Choose Brave

  • Living Brave
  • Brave Faith
  • Brave Marriage
  • Parenting Brave
  • Brave Friend

Why Love Must Defy Logic

by Katie

I could provide the details of the situation but it wouldn’t really matter anyhow. Next week the details will change.

I get frustrated at having to deal with the people in my life sometimes. Even my typed words smoke of arrogance, wreak of pride. Real people, real souls, that I have to deal with.

Sad.

I tend to sort them out transactionally, detach myself when things get messy and I ask why. Why does it have to be this way?

With a bowed head, but a heart crusted over, I present my requests to God.

God, why can’t she just be rational? It makes no sense to behave this way. I was kind, thoughtful even. And then this. It makes no sense.

Why can’t he be fair? It’s obvious I’ve done more than my share. I’m stressed and maxed. Can’t he just do his part?

It’s not even my fault, God. She is difficult. Emotional. Illogical. I’m over it.

Loving well is hard. Marriage is hard. In-law relationships and friendships are hard. But love must defy logic. This is the key we are often missing.

I’ve prayed these prayer far more times that I care to admit. I try to squeeze my situations into a sieve of logic, haplessly tossing whatever won’t drain through.

Her emotions? Not logical. Neediness? Not logical. Those demands, that ignorance, her brokenness? Sorry, not logical.

I straighten my back, stand a little taller, as I pour prayers out into my own warped scales (Proverbs 11:1). It’s so obvious I’m winning here.

But when I quiet my bargaining, I finally hear him. One simple question. He knew that is all it would take.

What about my love is logical, Katie?

There are none righteous, no, not one (Romans 3:10).

Righteous-er is not a word. Imagine that? I have convinced myself that it is. Not literally – because spell-check – but in deed, in prayer, in my heart.

What a corroded mess I’ve made in here – receiving love and pouring it out in weights and measures. Checking my dosage. Prescribing only in logic.

I am the unforgiving servant in Matthew 18, a receiver of grace far greater than I can, and sometimes even wish to, comprehend and yet I turn around and impose limitations based on my finite and so very limited logic.

 

Love defies logic. Proverbs 19:11

 

The other day a woman poured out her heart to me. She told stories I had never heard from a life I have never lived. She spoke of rejection I have never experienced and wounds that left gaping scars. Her story, her history, was so different than my own.

And while truth is always truth, our view of it comes in through different lenses. Hers and mine, they’re different.

How can I preach logical reactions when I don’t have the same scars, my view isn’t embedded in same very real history?

When we demand that love is logical then we demand that love is administered based on our own experience and understanding.

But God’s love is never logical. His death, his sacrifice for an ungrateful and forgetful people – for me – makes no sense whatsoever. And this is the love that we are asked to, by his grace, pour out.

Instead of meting out love and begging God to make the rest of the world abide by our logic, some better questions, better conversations, better prayers, sound something like this:

God how do you see her? Give me your heart for the people around me – for him, her, them. Replace my heart of stone with a heart of flesh, a heart more like yours. How can I love like you, Lord. Show me, teach me, change me as I lean not on my own understanding, but on your brilliant example. Let my love, like yours, defy logic and speak wildly of You.

 

In a warring world, where arguments seem unending. In a difficult marriage where differences seem to be around every corner. With tough friends and complicated families, unyielding children and co-workers that feel like sandpaper let’s pray for a love that defies logic. I’m convinced it makes a world of difference.

SaveSave

SaveSave

Share267
Email
Pin260
Print
Post
527Shares

You may also enjoy...

Filed Under: Brave Faith, Living Brave

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Shirley says

    September 6, 2017 at 5:14 am

    I was praying this morning for this very shortcoming in my life. That the walls in my life could be knocked down, even though I may not agree with or understand the next ones behaviour. To see myself more clearly. And then I opened your email….and WOW…Thank you…you have touched me through your own struggle you put into words. Thank you for bravely sharing. Pray for me.

    • Katie says

      September 6, 2017 at 5:30 am

      God is so good to meet us with words right when we need them, isn’t he? Though this concept is simple, Shirley, it most certainly is not always easy. Praying for you this morning. <3

  2. Amy Christensen says

    August 26, 2017 at 7:37 am

    Katie, this is such a good post! I needed to hear this today. My husband actually teaches Logic, so you can well imagine, it drives him crazy when things don’t add up. One day I finally said to him, “Mark, stop trying to make sense of it. It doesn’t make sense.” He told me that was the most freeing thing he had heard in a long time. Ha, ha. We live with so much brokenness, our own and others, it is only by His grace that we ever make any sense. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. – Amy
    http://stylingrannymama.com/

  3. Sheila Qualls says

    August 25, 2017 at 11:26 am

    Thought provoking post. Love is not logical. Nothing about it is. But yet, my heart hardens quickly. Thanks for pointing out something that is hidden in plain sight.

  4. Shawna says

    August 25, 2017 at 10:12 am

    My heart hurts at how short I fall in this area!! God’s love is so good and so full of grace and absolutely illogical-thank you for both the conviction and the cure to show that we can love like He does, if we will let Him live in us and change us. Thank you Katie for your words, and for being a vessel that the Lord can use. This encourages me to pray for a love like Jesus’. xoxo

  5. Katharine says

    August 25, 2017 at 9:39 am

    This is the exact issue that I have been grappling with over the summer. God has been showing me that I need to love in the way that he loves, to pour out grace in the way that he pours grace. I’m only just starting to see it, and your article is just what I needed to read. I’ve read it three times already just to try to get those truths to sink a little deeper into my heart. God bless you Katie!

    • Katie says

      August 25, 2017 at 9:49 am

      How sweet is it that He can connect us across the miles, as he is teaching us the very same thing? I love that! Thank you for sharing, Katharine.

  6. Fran says

    August 25, 2017 at 9:05 am

    Thank you so much for these words, Katie. They are so true and so needed to be spoken. Our concern should not be centered around how someone is or does but centered on seeing them as Christ does and aiming to minister to them where they are.

    • Katie says

      August 25, 2017 at 9:46 am

      It is so easy to focus on the “is” and “does”, isn’t it Fran? Thank you for your kind words.

Primary Sidebar

 

Katie Westenberg

Hey, friend, I’m glad you’re here! I’m Katie. One girl determined to do life bravely. One girl determined to Fear God and Live Brave, to parent well, live authentically and work hard for all the things that matter. I Choose Brave and I hope you will too!

Enter your e-mail address in the box below and join thousands of women in the brave community here. It’s the simplest way to keep in touch and stay encouraged!

Posts You’ll Love!

Raising Overcomers: How to Teach Your Kids to do Hard Things

Identity Crisis: How to Help Your Children Know Their Worth

The Power of a Mother’s Words

Pre-Order Now

But Then She Remembered

Buy This Book Online
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Amazon Kindle
Buy from Christian Book Distributor
Buy from Barnes and Noble
Baker Book House
But Then She Remembered
Buy now!
This is fun news! For a limited time, buy a copy o This is fun news! For a limited time, buy a copy of But Then She Remembered for MOM and we’ll send YOU a copy of the audiobook for free!

Distraction is a multi-generational struggle. Remembering is a multi-generational command. Let’s do this, together. Here are the details:

Purchase your copy of But Then She Remembered from any retailer and then head to my website (link in bio) to get your free copy of the audiobook. It’s that simple.
.
Available while supplies last. (Note: the offer says buy a copy for mom, not necessarily YOUR mom. Buy a copy for a woman who is a mom, or a woman who has a mom. 😊 They all qualify. Just grab it before they’re gone!}
I scanned a post shared by a friend awhile back an I scanned a post shared by a friend awhile back and the words quickly wooed me. I’ve long been a sucker for words.
.
The writer spun them expertly, thoughtfully, vividly, and I was glad to drink of her craft, greedy for story drawn artfully, delivered thoughtfully, from a deep well.

Until I realized, the words weren’t true. The author was believing a well woven lie and carefully threading mistruth into her own kind of gospel. Her mastery, a thin veil for mistruth.
.
I was reminded, friend, perhaps the apple looks a bit different today. The shape and size, delivery method, have gone modern but the Truth is still the same - sin is crouching, desiring us and we are commanded to rule over it. Still, today.
.
We must know Truth to spot lies. We must remember it, to recognize the difference. We must be aware of our weaknesses and the sticky compulsion of temptation. It’s our responsibility to rule here. May we do so, bravely..
.
{Genesis 4:7 
And more like this in the newly released, But Then She Remembered.}
This morning, remember. This morning, remember.
Just a little PSA to remind you - it’s possible. Just a little PSA to remind you - it’s possible. 

It’s possible to be aware of the news and the world, of foreign relations and politics, and not be obsessed about it.

It’s possible to feel the real hurt of real trouble and not be possessed by it.

It’s possible to be in the world and not of it. To remember who God was, and is, and always will be, above it.

It’s possible to remember Him here.

May we learn to do so, bravely.
.

{Beautifully modeled in Psalm 77. See for yourself, friend.❤️}
Slow processor over here. But this little book lau Slow processor over here. But this little book launched into the world on Tuesday and I’m still reeling from the beauty of celebrating side by side with so many sisters, the grace of what it looks like when so many women offer their gifts for His glory (fishes and loaves never looked so good!), and the incredible support of my local community. I’ll never forget it.
.
If you want to join us as women determined to remember the goodness of God in this wildly distracting world, grab yourself a copy of the book and LET’S GO! We are ready for it.❤️
HOW SWEET IS THIS? My dear friend @jodie_berndt an HOW SWEET IS THIS? My dear friend @jodie_berndt and I get to release books on the very same day - tomorrow! To celebrate @growthrootsco (another dear friend and creator of the loveliest journals) is giving YOU a chance to win copies of them all!

Here’s the offering:

1. My book - But then she remembered (how to give God your full attention in a distracted world)
2. Jodie’s book - Praying the scriptures for your marriage (trusting God with your most important relationship)
3. A growth book! 
4. Jodie’s favorite pens!
5. An Amazon gift card!! 
6. Marriage conversation cards! 

Beautiful, right? I know these women, their love for Jesus, their work and their words. You will LOVE these books, friend (and the extra goodies too). 

Here’s how to enter:

1. Follow @jodie_berndt, @katie_westenberg and @growthrootsco

2. Tag 3 friends (or more 😉 each tag or share gives you another entry) 

3. Like this post.

That’s it! The giveaway will close Wednesday night and the winner will be announced Thursday! 

*Giveaway open to U.S residents only. As per Instagram’s rules, this promotion is not sponsored, administered, or associated with Instagram in any way.*
The humanity of Jesus Christ is an indispensable g The humanity of Jesus Christ is an indispensable gift to us as believers. Every challenge we face He met and mastered. The Bible doesn’t speak of endless notifications and group texts, but it does speak of people with real needs showing up in Christ’s path constantly. 
.
Wherever He went crowds followed with needs and questions and frustrations and problems. He got in a boat to cross to the other side of the sea, and people would race to meet Him there. 

Can you even imagine?

And His most common response? He was moved with compassion. 
.
Over and over again, He stopped what He was doing, paused from the task at hand, and tended to the needy hearts - the bleeding woman, the woman at the well - right in front of Him.
.
Far too often I find I’m happy to entertain distractions - anything that prevents me from giving my full attention to something else - and yet annoyed by interruptions. Perhaps it is because one I choose, while the other I do not?
.
Discerning the difference between a distraction and an interruption has been a helpful tool to me. I want to love like Christ. I want to be interruptible, but I want to give my full attention to what He places in my path.
.
What about you? Are you more frustrated by distractions or interruptions?
.
.
.
{excerpt from But Then She Remembered: How to Give God Your Full Attention in a Distracted World.}
UPDATE: You all scooped up dozens of copies in min UPDATE: You all scooped up dozens of copies in minutes! 🎉 Well done! You know how to love your leaders well. I wish we had another case of books to give away! We are closing this giveaway for now. If you sent us a message watch for a reply soon!
****

I need your help with something fun! 
.
This little book is making its way out into the world and instead of sending all of the marketing copies to all of the “influencer” people, we’ve held a supply back for the real people on the ground. 
.
These copies are for the women’s ministry leaders and the Bible study leaders. The small group leaders and women out there mentoring and serving others in quiet and unseen places. The women without a platform or audience in the world’s currency, but willing to do good and important work for the women right in front of them.
.
I’m convinced this work of leading and serving face to face is more important than ever and I want to say thank you! And keep going! Your work matters.
.
So here is how it works: If you are a local leader or know of one who you would like me to send a copy of my hot-off-the-press book, But Then She Remembered: How to Give God Your Full Attention in a Distracted World, DM me with a name and mailing address. I’ll send them a copy of the book with a personal thank you note for the good work they are doing.
.
Crash my inbox. We’ll send ‘em out while supplies last!

Copyright © 2025 · Katie Westenberg · All Rights Reserved